As featured in
strategy
A testamentary trust is created by a provision in your Will. It comes into existence on your death, when the Will is proved. Property flows into the trust through probate.
A living trust (or 'inter vivos' trust) is created during the settlor's lifetime. Property is transferred to the trust immediately or over time. The trust operates while the settlor is alive.
Both types of trust can be revocable (settlor retains right to revoke) or irrevocable (permanent). Both can be discretionary or specific.
Simplicity of creation: the trust is a clause in your Will. No separate trust deed, no property transfer during your lifetime, no ongoing administration until death.
Full lifetime control: you retain complete ownership and control of assets until death. The trust does not affect your ability to transact.
Revocability: you can amend or revoke the testamentary trust simply by amending or revoking the Will. No formal partitioning or transfer required.
Lower ongoing cost: no annual trust administration, filings, or trustee fees during your lifetime.
Appropriate for smaller estates: the complexity of a living trust is not justified for estates under a certain size.
Property goes through probate before entering the trust. Probate can be slow and public. In Bombay presidency, probate is mandatory for most Wills.
Beneficiaries do not receive benefits until probate is complete. For time-sensitive needs (funding a minor's education, providing income to a widow), the probate delay is problematic.
Public disclosure: the Will (including trust terms) becomes public record during probate. For families valuing privacy, this is a drawback.
Contests: the testamentary trust is only as strong as the Will. Challenges to the Will threaten the trust structure.
Avoids probate: property already in the trust does not need to be probated. Beneficiaries can start receiving benefits immediately on the settlor's death (or per trust terms).
Privacy: the trust deed is not public. Family arrangements remain confidential.
Continuity: no gap between the settlor's death and the trust's operation. Business continuity, care for dependants, and other time-sensitive matters are not interrupted.
Incapacity planning: a living trust can continue functioning if the settlor becomes incapacitated (through age or illness). A Will does not help with incapacity.
Cross-border efficiency: living trusts often work better for cross-border estates where multiple probate proceedings would be required.
Higher setup cost: trust deed drafting is more complex than a Will's trust clause. Stamp duty and registration may apply.
Ongoing administration: annual trust accounting, tax filings, and trustee fees. Managing a trust is more work than managing personal assets.
Property transfer required: assets must be transferred to the trust during the settlor's lifetime. This creates present tax implications and paperwork.
Loss of some control: an irrevocable trust means the settlor no longer owns the property. Even a revocable trust involves trustee involvement in decisions.
Tax treatment: living trusts have specific Indian tax treatment that may not align with the settlor's preferences.
Estate is moderate (typically under ₹5 crore).
Wealth is straightforward — a single family, standard beneficiaries.
Settlor wants to retain complete control until death.
Setup complexity of a living trust is not justified.
No time-sensitive post-death needs that require pre-probate access to funds.
Probate is likely to be uncontested and relatively quick.
Estate is substantial (typically ₹5+ crore).
Assets are complex — business holdings, multiple properties, foreign assets.
Beneficiaries need continuity of support post-death without probate delays.
Family values privacy about wealth.
Settlor may become incapacitated and wants trust to continue managing.
Cross-border succession is likely to require multiple probate proceedings.
Family business succession needs to be seamless.
For many wealthy Indian families, the optimal structure combines both:
A living trust holds substantial family assets (business shares, investment portfolios, real estate).
A Will handles personal effects and any residuary assets not in the trust.
The Will includes a 'pour-over' clause directing any assets in the settlor's individual name at death to flow into the living trust.
This provides the benefits of both — living trust for the bulk of the estate, Will for flexibility and completeness.
Living trusts have specific Indian tax treatment: revocable trusts are taxed to the settlor, irrevocable specific trusts to beneficiaries, irrevocable discretionary trusts to trustees at maximum marginal rate.
Testamentary trusts are taxed similarly to living trusts once they come into operation post-death.
For substantial trusts, tax optimisation requires coordination between advocate and chartered accountant.
1. Advocate drafts trust deed capturing purpose, beneficiaries, trustees, powers, distribution rules, amendment mechanism.
2. Trust deed is executed and registered (mandatory registration in most states for immovable-property trusts).
3. Stamp duty paid per state rates.
4. Trust obtains PAN.
5. Trust bank account opened.
6. Assets transferred to trust — bank accounts, investments, real estate title.
7. Ongoing annual tax filings and administration begin.
Setup cost: ₹1-3 lakh for standard trusts, more for complex structures. Ongoing: ₹50,000-₹3 lakh annually depending on complexity.
Trust choice is a significant decision. Consult a Law Tarazoo advocate with trust experience.
For substantial estates, this is Succession Planning (₹1,00,000) territory. The 12-month engagement covers trust design, drafting, coordination with other estate documents, and initial administration setup.
This is general legal information, not legal advice. For your specific situation, consult a Law Tarazoo advocate.
Start with the ₹5,000 Online Will — advocate-reviewed, delivered in your inbox in 30 minutes. Or book a 60-minute Personalised consult at ₹25,000.
Start My Will →
